Hello!
Time for my impressions of the episode of the week :-) I like this episode although it is not one of my favourites - mainly because of the illogical parts. On the plus side are the scenes with the UFO attacking Roper in his car, Dawson attacking Carol and the scenes on the Moon, which are all very dramatic and moody (well, at least IMO :-) And this I have noticed: * Roper is driving home (in Straker's car? :-) at night. This is a so-called "day-for-night" shot: it is shot at a sunny day using a blue filter and the lenses were adjusted two diaphragms smaller (I hope this is right word?) To intensify the night effect the car lights were switched on too. Simple, isn't it? * When the phone rings at Roper's home he put it up immediateley, waits about seven seconds before he held the receiver to his ear and then he hears a voice saying "Hello Roper! How's your wife?" That's really scary. The caller knows when Roper has the receiver in the right position so that he can hear him! * Roper's license number ist A21 384. Have to look what Straker's number is... (maybe Roper lend the car from his boss :-) That would explain the reaction of Straker when he was told that Roper crashed with his car :-)) * At Roper's inquisition, Straker says amazingly rather softly: "Come on, come on...". Freeman comments this with: "You're pushing him to hard!" I found that always amusing :-) * Look out: when Ford announces the Maximum Security Alert to all SHADO stations one can see a close-up of Straker which was used in "Identified" first. You see, not only FX scenes were re-used in other eps. * Okay, Maximum Security Alert. But why are the Mobiles operational? That's of no use since nobody knows where they should be stationed. Same goes to the Interceptors: why are they lifting off - without a known mark? After all Space is a too large sphere for this kind of action. Yes, I know the answer: it's for the action and it looks dramatic ;-) * In this episode the UFO is at least more than two days in Earth atmosphere - without exploding. So what? * The chasing of Roper by the UFO is well done. I like it, I like it! 8-)) * Dawson was prepared by the Aliens with an electronic probe; the Aliens refine their methods to take possession of Earthmen in the episode The Psychobombs. * The whole business with this flight path is a little bit to thin for my taste. Is it really so complicated to find out what's the flight path for? And do the Aliens really need this kind of information? Anyone? * And then this "One-man-on-a-suicide mission": what's so suicide on this mission? Why not sending out four or more men armed with rocket launchers to start a cross-fire at the UFO? Why only one man? (And why the weakest man at this moment?) And why - for God's sake - must Roper go the whole long way ON FOOT??? Instead using a Moonmobile??? Oh, just forget it.... :-/ * Straker is a really tough guy in this ep. "Maybe he never need to know..." which implicates that Straker doesn't expect the comeback of Roper from this mission... Nice boss <shudder> * Isn't Roper interested to speak to his wife after the UFO has attacked him? After all he must recognise that some things went wrong and therefore his wife could be in danger too... Okay, he said on Moonbase that he couldn't call her, but sorry: if this were MY wife I would move Heaven and Hell to speak to my beloved one! Especially when I have to go on a "suicide mission". * Gay Ellis tells Roper that "a Moonhopper is on it's way. It'll be with you in minutes." In minutes? When the Moonmobile needs MINUTES to reach the place, then how much time has Roper needed to reach it - going ON FOOT! SHADO treats their personal not very kindly. :-/ That's all for this time :-) CU Christian Oh yeah... have almost forgot my bestowed title (hihi): The Master ;-)) |
Administrator
|
More great comments, Christian!
You wrote: >* Look out: when Ford announces the Maximum Security Alert to all >SHADO stations one can see a close-up of Straker which was used in >"Identified" first. In this case, I think that this scene was originally filmed for FLIGHT PATH, and then later inserted into IDENTIFIED. The original scripts for both episodes are on my website, and you'll see that this scene is scripted for FLIGHT PATH, but not IDENTIFIED! -- Marc Martin, [hidden email] |
In reply to this post by Christian J.
[hidden email] wrote:
> Hello! Heya! > Time for my impressions of the episode of the week :-) Me too! :-) > I like this episode although it is not one of my favourites - mainly > because of the illogical parts. On the plus side are the scenes with > the UFO attacking Roper in his car, Dawson attacking Carol and the > scenes on the Moon, which are all very dramatic and moody (well, at > least IMO :-) And this I have noticed: I never really cared for this ep myself, although the car crash scene is impressive - with no way for Roper to survive, though ... > * Roper is driving home (in Straker's car? :-) at night. This is > a so-called "day-for-night" shot: it is shot at a sunny day using a > blue filter and the lenses were adjusted two diaphragms smaller (I > hope this is right word?) To intensify the night effect the car > lights were switched on too. Simple, isn't it? Errrrrrr, yeah, sure ... <blink> > * When the phone rings at Roper's home he put it up immediateley, > waits about seven seconds before he held the receiver to his ear and > then he hears a voice saying "Hello Roper! How's your wife?" > That's really scary. The caller knows when Roper has the receiver > in the right position so that he can hear him! Must have been watching him <looking spooked> > * Roper's license number ist A21 384. Have to look what > Straker's number is... (maybe Roper lend the car from his boss > :-) That would explain the reaction of Straker when he was told that > Roper crashed with his car :-)) I know I have researched this bit - the license plate number, I mean, but I don't remember what I found. <sigh> > * At Roper's inquisition, Straker says amazingly rather softly: > "Come on, come on...". Freeman comments this with: "You're > pushing him to hard!" I found that always amusing :-) LOL! It is weird that Straker does the interrogation via video - only reason I can come with is he must not want to bother leaving his office. Tiger says, "He's a lazy SOB, isn't he?" ;-) > * Look out: when Ford announces the Maximum Security Alert to all > SHADO stations one can see a close-up of Straker which was used in > "Identified" first. You see, not only FX scenes were re-used in other > eps. Really? > * Okay, Maximum Security Alert. But why are the Mobiles operational? > That's of no use since nobody knows where they should be > stationed. Same goes to the Interceptors: why are they lifting off - > without a known mark? After all Space is a too large sphere for this > kind of action. Yes, I know the answer: it's for the action and > it looks dramatic ;-) Didn't they know where the UFOs where coming in at? <ponder> OKay, I was only half watching, never mind .... > * In this episode the UFO is at least more than two days in Earth > atmosphere - without exploding. So what? It was under water, wasn't it? > * The chasing of Roper by the UFO is well done. I like it, I like it! > 8-)) Except there was no way for Roper to survive that crash! The car went into the air, flipped over and crashed upside down. The gullwinged dorrs may have flung open when the car was in the air and Roper could have fallen out, but he would have fallen out right OVER the flaming station - he'd of been toasted. > * Dawson was prepared by the Aliens with an electronic probe; the > Aliens refine their methods to take possession of Earthmen in the > episode The Psychobombs. LOL! True ..... And same question - the aliens are always trying to kill Straker (look at the lengths they went to in Kill Straker), so why didn't they have Dawson (was that his name? - shows how much attention I paid <sigh>) kill Straker? Same with that guy in Psychobombs who flung Straker across the car like a rag doll - could have just killed him ....... > * The whole business with this flight path is a little bit to thin > for my taste. Is it really so complicated to find out what's the > flight path for? And do the Aliens really need this kind of > information? Anyone? YES! THANK YOU! My thoughts exactly - like the aliens are too stupid to figure it out by themselves. Which, actually, they MUSt have figured it out, since they knew Roper had given them the wrong coordinates! > * And then this "One-man-on-a-suicide mission": what's so suicide > on this mission? Why not sending out four or more men armed with > rocket launchers to start a cross-fire at the UFO? Why only one man? > (And why the weakest man at this moment?) > And why - for God's sake - must Roper go the whole long way > ON FOOT??? Instead using a Moonmobile??? Oh, just forget it.... :-/ <nod nod nod nodnodnodnod> RIGHT! > * Straker is a really tough guy in this ep. "Maybe he never need to > know..." which implicates that Straker doesn't expect the > comeback of Roper from this mission... Nice boss <shudder> Roper's wife was a wienie, though, wasn't she? Why just stand there and let the wounded guy get his gun and shoot her? She could have kicked the gun out of his reach, run into the bed room and locked the door, run out the door, for crying out loud! Sniffling wienie <hmph> > * Isn't Roper interested to speak to his wife after the UFO has > attacked him? After all he must recognise that some things went wrong > and therefore his wife could be in danger too... Okay, he said on > Moonbase that he couldn't call her, but sorry: if this were MY > wife I would move Heaven and Hell to speak to my beloved one! > Especially when I have to go on a "suicide mission". He may have known ... > * Gay Ellis tells Roper that "a Moonhopper is on it's way. > It'll be with you in minutes." In minutes? When the Moonmobile > needs MINUTES to reach the place, then how much time has Roper needed > to reach it - going ON FOOT! SHADO treats their personal not very > kindly. :-/ LOL! I thought Roper stepped out the door and was right there at the rock - I don't know why he couldn't just walk back in! > That's all for this time :-) > CU Christian > Oh yeah... have almost forgot my bestowed title (hihi): > The Master ;-)) LOL! -- Yuchtar -- =+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+= Yuchtar zantai-Klaan | [hidden email] I am not a number! I am a FREE FAN! =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= "They want the federal government to control Social Security like it was some kind of federal program." -- George W. Bush =+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+= http://yuchtar.users4.50megs.com/ http://nunzie.users2.50megs.com/ |
Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |