Hi All,
As computer technology marches forwards, I've been playing around and have created the following UFO theme MP3, which is higher quality than the one that's been on my website for the past couple years: http://ufo.simplenet.com/beg.mp3 However, this raises an interesting question -- is higher quality neccessarily better? This version is so crisp that I can now hear flaws in the original performance, which is kind of annoying. Any opinions? Of course, if you have cheap computer speakers, I don't think you're going to hear any difference, so it's probably not worth the download... -- Marc Martin, [hidden email] P.S. Dave, don't replace the track on your UFO soundtrack CD with this one... I think we can save this for volume 2... ;-) |
Marc Martin wrote:
> > P.S. Dave, don't replace the track on your UFO soundtrack CD with > this one... I think we can save this for volume 2... ;-) > I'd been led to believe that the material presented on Dave's pirate CDs was not available elsewhere (the UFO theme is certainly available on at least one commercial release) - is this not the case? James |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin-2
James writes:
>I'd been led to believe that the material presented on Dave's >pirate CDs was not available elsewhere (the UFO theme is certainly >available on at least one commercial release) - is this not the >case? Well, first things first... we need to review which commercial releases contain the UFO theme. Then, we need to eliminate all cover versions. Then, we need to eliminate versions which include the teletype noise (Cult Files). Then, we need to eliminate the ones which used the wrong take of the music (Sci-Fi Channel). What does that leave us? Is the original UFO theme available actually available commercially? As of a few years ago the answer was "no", but I suppose things might have changed and I just didn't notice... -- Marc Martin, [hidden email] |
Marc Martin wrote:
> James writes: > >I'd been led to believe that the material presented on Dave's > >pirate CDs was not available elsewhere (the UFO theme is certainly > >available on at least one commercial release) - is this not the > >case? > > Well, first things first... we need to review which commercial > releases contain the UFO theme. Then, we need to eliminate > all cover versions. Then, we need to eliminate versions which > include the teletype noise (Cult Files). Then, we need to eliminate > the ones which used the wrong take of the music (Sci-Fi Channel). > > What does that leave us? Is the original UFO theme available > actually available commercially? As of a few years ago the > answer was "no", but I suppose things might have changed and > I just didn't notice... > I was thinking of the Cult Files release, with the teletype noise. OK - I take your point that it's a slightly different version, but it is, after all, essentially the same tune. I think it's reasonable to suppose that some folks who just want a copy of the theme music might not particularly care whether the teletype noise was present, and it's unfortunate therefore that in one or two cases, the copyright owners won't be getting their fair due. BTW on second thoughts, I shouldn't really have used the term 'pirate' in my last mail - I realise that these CDs aren't being passed off as official releases. Apologies to everyone who finds the copyright issue boring - I'll stop now. Regards James |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin-2
>OK - I take your point that it's a slightly different version,
>but it is, after all, essentially the same tune. I think it's >reasonable to suppose that some folks who just want a copy of the >theme music might not particularly care whether the teletype The version on the Cult Files CD is essentially just a recording off of a videotape of the show. It's not derived from the higher quality recordings that Barry Gray originally recorded for the series. And for some of us, this makes a difference. Heck, I think this new version I uploaded today is *much* different than the version I've had on my music page, but like you say, there are folks who probably couldn't tell the difference between a cover version and the real thing. Also, please note that the UFO theme on the Cult Files CD is also not complete, because the end theme fades into and obscures the beginning of the music. So I think this version is clearly unnacceptable. But I'm sure if there's another CD which has a complete, non-teletype version of the UFO theme, somebody on this mailing list must know about it. I have many CD's containing UFO themes on them, but they are mostly cover versions or messed up. I know that Fanderson gave out an EP back in 1988 which had the original version, but this was never available "commercially", and is certainly not something you could buy from them for the past 10 years. So somebody name the CD, and I will buy it today! (pulls out credit card) :-) -- Marc Martin, [hidden email] |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin-2
At 10:40 AM 4/27/00 -0700, you wrote:
>Hi All, > >As computer technology marches forwards, I've been playing around >and have created the following UFO theme MP3, which is higher quality >than the one that's been on my website for the past couple years: > > http://ufo.simplenet.com/beg.mp3 > >However, this raises an interesting question -- is higher quality >neccessarily better? This version is so crisp that I can now >hear flaws in the original performance, which is kind of annoying. > >Any opinions? > >Of course, if you have cheap computer speakers, I don't >think you're going to hear any difference, so it's probably not >worth the download... > >-- >Marc Martin, [hidden email] > >P.S. Dave, don't replace the track on your UFO soundtrack CD with >this one... I think we can save this for volume 2... ;-) AAAAAAARRRRRRGGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!!! You let the cat out of the bag! And we haven't even started production yet! Everyone, pay no attention to the man behind the curtain, he has no idea what he's blabbing about, there is no UFO Volume II CD available yet! Just give us a couple months... "Ninety percent of science-fiction is crud. That's because ninety percent of everything is crud." Theodore Sturgeon Dave Walsh Harlington-Straker Sound Productions [hidden email] http://home.earthlink.net/~voidspider/ |
In reply to this post by James Gibbon-2
James Gibbon <[hidden email]> wrote:-
> I'd been led to believe that the material presented on Dave's > pirate CDs was not available elsewhere (the UFO theme is certainly > available on at least one commercial release) - is this not the case? Could this "pirate" version of the UFO theme be a re-playing and re-recording? |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin-2
>Apologies to everyone who finds the copyright issue boring -
>I'll stop now. > >Regards >James > > Thank you! All the best, Branko ________________________________________________________________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin-2
Toto, I don't think were in Kansas anymore
Dave Wtote: > AAAAAAARRRRRRGGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!!! You let the cat out of the bag! And >we >haven't even started production yet! Everyone, pay no attention to the man >behind the curtain, he has no idea what he's blabbing about, there is no >UFO Volume II CD available yet! > > Just give us a couple months... > > > > "Ninety percent of science-fiction is crud. That's because > ninety percent of everything is crud." > Theodore Sturgeon > > Dave Walsh > Harlington-Straker Sound Productions > [hidden email] > http://home.earthlink.net/~voidspider/ > > >------------------------------------------------------------------------ >Get 3 months FREE and a chance to WIN a trip to London, England when >you receive, manage and pay your bills online with Paytrust.com! >Stamps, checks and bills in your mailbox are history. Enroll Today! >http://click.egroups.com/1/3556/7/_/_/_/956908168/ >------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > ________________________________________________________________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com |
In reply to this post by Marc Martin-2
I wrote:
>Also, please note that the UFO theme on the Cult Files CD is also >not complete, because the end theme fades into and obscures the >beginning of the music. So I think this version is clearly >unnacceptable. Some mistakes in the above statement -- I was thinking not of a "Cult Files" CD, but a "This is... Cult Fiction Royale". The UFO track starts with the end theme which blends into the Century 21 sting (ruining both of these), which is immediately followed by the main theme with teletype sound effects. The main theme is fortunately not destroyed by the fading. -- Marc Martin, [hidden email] |
Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |